Thursday, September 8, 2011
The Bluest Eye: "Summer"
She, however, stepped over into madness, a madness which protected her from us simply because it bored us in the end." (205-206)
This passage stood out to me becauseit plays with the difference between fantasy and madness. In their fantasies, people can create who they want to be. The contradictions Morrison expresses how strong people are actually only aggressive. She tells us how these people live false lives. Typically, fantasies are dream like creations;however, Morrison's diction creates an idea that these fantasies have consumed their lives. The adult's lives have become facades every day. This fantasy word is shown in full detail with Mrs. Breedlove and her life as Polly. However, in Pecola's madness, she finally finds true protection. Throughout the whole novel, Pecola is victimized. Claudia and Frieda still stick with her and even protect her but when she is finally crumbled into madness, they simply lose interest. It was interesting to me how fantasies became second lives and madness was a boring protection in the end.
Q:What did they assassinate that Pecola looked for in the Dumpster?
SUMMER
In this passage, Claudia is summarizing how the community felt about Pecola and ultimately how they used her. She was merely an object to the people of Lorain, an object they could wash themselves on. In hindsight, Claudia describes how in comparison to Pecola and her unfortunate circumstances, Claudia and Frieda, and presumably the rest of the community felt "sanctified", "wholesome", "strong", "eloquent" and "decorated". She was a tool for them to elevate themselves with and a scapegoat on which they could dump their own self-hatred and guilt. However, Pecola did not put up much of a fight, instead she "abosorbed" it. Because of this, one could argue that Pecola may be the most important and central character in the entire novel. Without Pecola to blame, where would the people of Lorain be? From Claudia's perspective, hating Pecola was the only thing that kept everyone's minds off of hating themselves, and calling Pecola ugly was the only thing that kept everyone's from feeling ugly themselves. Claudia even says that all of their beauty was "hers first which she gave to us". She acknowledges the beauty in Pecola's appearance and character but how it was quickly sacrificed for the sake of the town. I would argue that Pecola could be deemed the heroin of the novel in the way that she, whether intentionally or not, consistently laid herself down to be a stepping stool for the people around her. Ironically, though everyone seemed to have hated her so much, it's almost as if the community would've fallen apart without her.
-Annie Baker
Q: To what degree is Pecola aware of her position as scapegoat? Does she think her situation could be different?
Summer
The Bluest Eye: Summer
“Our sorrow drove out all thoughts of the new bicycle. And I believe our sorrow was the more intense because nobody else seemed to share it. They were disgusted, amused, shocked, outraged, or even excited by the story. But we listened for the one who would say, “Poor little girl,” or, “Poor baby,” but there was only head-wagging where those words should have been. We looked for eyes creased with concern, but saw only veils.” (190)
This quote appears in the novel in the “Summer” chapter when Claudia and Freida had returned from the homes in their community that they visited in an attempt to sell seeds for five cents each in hopes of earning enough money for a new bicycle. The women of the town could not resist talking about the latest gossip, even in the presence of the two young girls, and Freida and Claudia piece together what happened to Pecola.
I was struck by the depiction of the “disgusted, amused, shocked, outraged” women in this quote because although they share many characteristics with Pecola, they refuse to give her the benefit of the doubt when arguing whether or not she attempted to fight off Cholly. Also, they do not take her side even after she was raped by her father and beaten by her mother. Freida and Claudia recognize that they are the only people who truly feel sorry for Pecola and hope that the baby lives.
Morrison uses the imagery of a veil to illustrate the way that the women of Lorain hid their true feelings about Pecola and refused to become too concerned for the ugly little girl. The veil also points to the major theme of vision in the novel. When someone wears a veil, they can neither see nor be seen. This is entirely appropriate for the women, who refuse to acknowledge the horrible truth of what happened with the Breedloves and instead hide in the safety of their own homes, behind the words that they throw around carelessly, and of which the Breedloves will never know. This quote gives us both an example of the compassionate character that the MacTeer girls and the lack of integrity that the women of Lorain possess.
Cami Morrow
Wednesday, September 7, 2011
Bluest Eye : Summer
p. 204
This quote further reiterates the adversity of rejection that Pecola faces all throughout the novel. She encounters and faces denial of acceptance through every person she comes across. Her lack of beauty is continually mentioned by every other character and is always described negatively . She is lonely out of her wits ; however, the only people that deem her worthy of attention are the "ruined" women of the town. Ultimately, this may be considered as a sort of irony. For the most part, this supports the notion that no matter how hard she "flaps her wings", and attempts to overcome this hill ; everyone around her brings her down in every way possible and places her in an inevitable lonesome hole.
Why would Frieda and Claudia avoid Pecola after they failed her ? If they were clever enough to realize that nobody else cared for her why would they abandon her if they wholeheartedly wanted to help ?
The Bluest Eye: Summer
“But suppose. Suppose a long way off. In Cincinnati, say, there is somebody whose eyes are bluer than mine? Suppose there are two people with bluer eyes? So what? You asked for blue eyes. You got blue eyes. He should have made them bluer” (202-203).
Toward the end of the last section of the book, it is revealed to the reader that Pecola has been granted her wish of blue eyes. This excerpt is from the conversation Pecola has with what seems to be an imaginary friend. For pages, Pecola goes on and on about her new eyes. However, her obsession and external joy seems to be veiling her true uncertainty and perhaps discontent with the results of her dream come true. At first, she seems to be bragging about her blue eyes and even accuses her friend of being jealous. This, I believe is the denial stage of the conversation. She is denying to herself that perhaps these blue eyes she wanted so badly, are not going to bring her true happiness. She is finally like Shirley Temple, like Maureen Peel, like the little white girl her mother cares for so dearly, yet she still seeks reassurance. She needs to know, to be told by someone else, that her eyes are beautiful and better than all of the other blue eyes. Throughout her conversation, she becomes less and less sure of her blue eyes. She starts to question whether she is the only one who has them. If not, are blue eyes enough? Now, instead of blue eyes, Pecola wants the bluest eyes, saying, “He should have made them bluer.” She is now taking this incredible gift for granted and deems her blue eyes not enough. Will anything ever be enough?
This is a perfect illustration of the old saying, “the grass is always greener.” As humans, we always want what we don’t have and we always think that when we get it we will find true happiness. Morrison makes an important point that human nature is naïve. Pecola is naïve in thinking that eye color will make her beautiful and accepted. Her innocence is shown in her belief that a dream can become reality and remain dreamlike. It is as if blue eyes will ensure that she will never be left again, that her mother will love her, that she will have friends, etc. Pecola believed that with blue eyes, all the bad things would go away. This is a childlike concept, but I believe that Pecola learned it from her mother. Morrison is making an important point that parents influence their child whether they realize it or not. Pauline searches for acceptance and love in the family she works for, which she has made into her fantasy life. Pecola witnesses her mother’s happiness in the home she works in and with the daughter of the family. In turn, Pecola believes that making her dream come true will put her in the same world of happiness as her mother, the world of the pretty, blue-eyed white girl.
Q: Does Pauline realize that she does have an impact on Pecola? If so, is she capable of being a good role model for her?
-Amber Riley
The Bluest Eye: Summer
"The birdlike gestures are worn away to a mere picking and plucking her way between the tire rims and the sunflowers, between Coke bottles and milkweed, among all the waste and beauty of the world—which is what she herself was. All of our waste which we dumped on her and which she absorbed. And all of our beauty, which was hers first and which she gave to us."
This passage provides a vital summary of the way the community has viewed Pecola. Throughout the entire novel, Pecola is seen as the scapegoat of the community. The community exploited Pecola her entire life. By pushing their "waste" on her, the community became more beautiful and rid themselves of waste. Even just observing Pecola's miserable life was enough to make a person feel better about their own life. Claudia explains the community's relationship to Pecola as if they traded their waste for her beauty. By hating Pecola, the community was able to rid themselves of their own self-hatred. People see her blackness as ugliness. It's ironic that Claudia chooses to acknowledge Pecola's madness as beauty when she's always thought Pecola was ugly. Claudia describes Pecola as a beautiful symbol for the suffering of society. Claudia realizes that Pecola's physical ugliness is what makes other people feel physically beautiful and that Pecola is in fact beautiful because she is human. She sees now that Pecola is a beautiful human for taking on the burdens of the community and absorbing them. She bore the burdens of so many other people and they felt "wholesome" after they cleaned themselves on her.
Q: Is it really "much, much, much too late" to save Pecola or is there a way that her sanity could be restored?
-Molly Cook
The Bluest Eye: Summer
"Which is what she herself was. All of our waste which we dumped on her and which she absorbed. And all of our beauty, which was hers first and which she gave to us. All of us--all who knew her--felt so wholesome after we cleaned ourselves on her. We were so beautiful when we stood astride her ugliness." (205)
Tuesday, September 6, 2011
The Bluest Eye: Spring
“Their voices blended into a threnody of nostalgia about pain. Rising and falling, complex in harmony, uncertain in pitch, but constant in the recitative of pain. They hugged the memories of illnesses to their bosoms. They licked their lips and clucked their tongues in fond remembrance of pains they had endured…” (137)
This quotation, given as insight from Cholly’s past, reveals to the reader a scene in which Aunt Jimmy’s friends reminisce on their past, more specifically directed toward the aspects of pain and all the memories associated with these feelings. The words embedded throughout this text are noticeably not the typical words associated with thoughts of pain. I think this is because even though these occurrences may have been painful in the moment, when looking back these women realize that this was not the case in context. The vocabulary used is almost lyrical as if they are singing a beautiful, complex song that composes the melody of their past.
The Bluest Eye: Spring
Monday, September 5, 2011
The Bluest Eye: Spring
“The little girl in pink started to cry. Mrs. Breedlove turned to her. ‘Hush, baby, hush. Come here. Oh, Lord, look at your dress. Don’t cry no more. Polly will change it.’ She went to the sink and turned tap water on a fresh towel. Over her shoulder she spit out words to us like rotten pieces of apple. ‘Pick up that wash and get on out of here, so I can get this mess cleaned up.’
Pecola picked up the laundry bag, heavy with wet clothes, and we stepped hurriedly out the door. As Pecola put the laundry bag in the wagon, we could hear Mrs. Breedlove hushing and soothing the tears of the little pink-and-yellow girl.
‘Who were they, Polly?’
‘Don’t worry none, baby.’” (109)
This section (and parts before and after it) further reinforces the “white is beautiful, black is ugly” stereotype. Mrs. Breedlove has a world she’s created in her employer’s home, a world that is all white and clean and perfect. She ignores her other life, her home and her family, which she lets fall into disrepair. She wants to lose who she is, and at her job she can do that, only accepting the best food and products for her white employers, who she receives much praise from, and even a new name, or nickname at least.
When the three girls enter the house she works in, enter her clean white world, it’s an annoyance to her, and when Pecola knocks a pie onto the floor, “splattering blackish blueberries everywhere” (which I think highlights a connection between blackness and mess) she doesn’t care that her own daughter may have been badly burned, even pushes her into the spilled juice. She also speaks about it being “her floor” that is now messed up, she wants that house and life to be her real life.
Every time Mrs. Breedlove talks to the black girls, her voice is described as rotten and dark, whereas when she talks to the blonde white girl, her voice is soothing and full of honey. She seems to have replaced Pecola with the little white girl, who she thinks of as the beautiful daughter she wanted. When the white girl asks about Pecola and the others, Polly avoids the question, again showing that she wants to forget about her real family.
--John Schaefer
The Bluest Eye: Spring
“Then she stopped staring at the green chairs, at the delivery truck; she went to the movies instead. There in the dark her memory was refreshed, and she succumbed to her earlier dreams. Along with the idea of romantic love, she was introduced to another – physical beauty. Probably the most destructive ideas in the history of human thought. Both originated in envy, thrived in insecurity, and ended in disillusion. In equating physical beauty with virtue, she stripped her mind, bound it, and collected self-contempt by the heap.” (122)
This excerpt provides vital insight into Mrs. Breedlove’s character, revealing the source of her distorted outlook on life. The movies expose Pauline to a world of beauty, luxury, and romance that she is now doomed to compare everyone and everything to. Unsatisfied with her own life in the shadow of the cinema’s manufactured image of perfection, Pauline’s relationship with her family disintegrates. As she realizes that Cholly can never live up to the romantic ideal set by film actors, her love for him gives way to exploitation of his faults for her own selfish gain. Having determined that her missing front tooth will never allow her to be “beautiful” like Jean Harlow, Pauline is forced to seek acceptance in her community through other means. In an effort to appear more righteous than her peers, she portrays herself as a martyr who has been commanded by God to punish Cholly for his sins. Cholly, in turn, uses Pauline as a receptacle for his hatred. This mutual manipulation creates a dysfunctional home environment that eventually destroys the family entirely.
When Pecola is born, Pauline immediately labels her as “ugly” and, since she associates physical beauty with value, is never able to truly love her. This supposed ugliness haunts Pecola throughout her childhood and undermines her self-esteem. Instead of taking care of her own home and family, Pauline begins to live vicariously through the white family she works for; she perfects their lavish household and dotes on their beautiful blonde daughter while neglecting her own. Pauline’s welcome acceptance of the nickname “Polly” bestowed upon her by her white employers also mirrors the rejection of her own “ugly” black identity. The unattainable standards set by the movies prove devastating to both Pauline’s own self-esteem and that of her family, reiterating the novel’s theme of the danger of equating whiteness with beauty.
Q: Do the unfortunate circumstances that shaped Pauline’s and Cholly’s lives excuse them for their cruel actions, or should they be held accountable for the damage they inflicted upon Pecola?
The Bluest Eye: "Spring"
This single paragraph reveals why it is Pecola is so easily victimized and why she never stands up for herself in anyway. She is afraid. At home there is no source of reassurance of any kind that validates her existence. Normally, if one is bullied and they have any kind of self-confidence or strength they'll lash out externally and fight, like Claudia and Frieda do, instead of withering away internally. The reason they can have the strength to fight is because at home they seem to receive so kind of love and support from their parents, but Mrs. Breedlove only gives fear to Pecola. So, without any help at home Pecola has no means to gather strength to fight back and instead becomes the helpless creature she acts like.
"Spring" is a fitting title for this section. In this section, the author reveals the plantings of the troubles which surrounds Pecola. Planting is associated with the season Spring. And the seeds of fear planted by Mrs. Breedlove in Pecola explain all that happens to her. She fears her father so she can't fight back against him. She fears other people so she goes to Soaphead Church to get blue eyes so she will be pretty like the others and have no reason for fear. Given the section's title and the contents, the central idea of this section seems to be that adults will force their hardships and pains on children who aren't aware of how to fight back, as though merely planting an innocent little seed. The above paragraph reveals how Mrs. Breedlove is forcing her pain on her children by pushing fear into them.
My question is how delusional, broken must Pecola seem if Soaphead Church believes she will believe she has blue eyes now?
The Bluest Eye: Spring
This particular passage is taken from the last section of spring in which we as the readers are introduced to a character named Elihue Micah Whitcomb, also known as Soaphead Church. It begins by describing his family history as well as his upbringing which is extremely important in understanding why he has become the horrible person that he is. Having been fortunate enough to come from a “noble” background Soaphead received an excellent education along with a love for the Caucasian race. This follows along with the constant theme throughout the novel that being white is better or more beautiful. It also gives this section a very condescending tone in which a copious amount of difficult language is thrown at the readers. We continue on to learn that most everything that is associated with bodily functions repulses him and ultimately leads him to become a pedophile.
I feel that this quote is important for many different reasons. First of all it shows us exactly what type of person Soaphead is and how he justifies his horrible assaults against these children. The wording indicates that he thinks it's ok to have sex with little girls because it would be unclean to perform these acts with consenting adults. Judging by the tone of the first sentence and the word "smacked" I am led to assume that these encounters were most likely very violent. I also think the word "innocence" is well used because the only thing that is innocent about these situations are the children. Also by committing these acts he is in fact stealing their innocence away from them. It is ironic that he believes himself to be a "very clean old man" because in fact he is what society would consider an extremely dirty old man.
-Jonathan Virdell
Thursday, September 1, 2011
The Bluest Eye: Winter
Winter, The Bluest Eye
Morrison has this long, descriptive narrative about a very unhappy woman with no real cause for her unhappiness. Everything in the world has gone right for her, but she just looks at it with a blank expression and moves on to the next thing. She has managed to do this with even the most precious things in life, including her son, but excluding one very fortunate cat. Somewhere in this woman's thoughts, the instructions for raising children and raising animals were mistakenly switched. This child somehow learns to adjust anyways, even without most of the emotional guidance most children need.
Junior, this child, brings to mind the hassle that childhood is in this novel. He can't do anything, and no one is really interested in helping him out. His own mother, who is responsible for this, is useless, but he can't do anything to antagonize his mother, because she'll just punish him. He learns that the only way he's going to get through his early onset angst is to transfer it to something that won't hurt him as badly as his mother. Morrison just seems to have a real thing against childhood, at least in this novel. Being young means being helpless and foolish. It really makes me wonder if it is truly better to be young and innocent and not have a care in the world, or know it all and fear it all and hate it all. It's not really the easiest thing to answer.
And not only that, it makes a point about people. They don't want to acknowledge that they are at fault; they always want someone else to blame. Geraldine blames her people, Junior, the cat.